
With near-perfect execution, The Rise of the Golden Idol is a must-play for any adventure fan.
91
Verdict
93%
Steam
89
IGDB
Verdict score based on confidence-adjusted Steam reviews?
Very Positive on Steam (93% positive from 3.8K reviews)
Critically acclaimed (89/100 critic average)
Compelling narrative and story
Rich open world to explore
No significant drawbacks reported
The Rise of the Golden Idol is a 2024 puzzle video game developed by Color Gray Games and published by Playstack for PC and console and Netflix Games for mobile platforms. It is the sequel to the 2022 game The Case of the Golden Idol. The game received generally positive reviews. Four downloadable expansions were released over 2025: The Sins of New Wells, The Lemurian Phoenix, The Age of Restraint, and The Curse of the Last Reaper.

Runs well on modern hardware.
Last updated 18d ago
Even more of a banger than the first. If you intend to play it, no need to know anything else. It's a rare occurrence that a detective game has a great mystery at its core that isn't also easy to solve. The clues are often subtle, some useless, some are there to throw you off, it often leads you to wrong assumptions without you realizing. You start with seemingly random and unrelated scenes. It feels great when you start seeing the connections to everything later. It's better played without long breaks in between, if there are any it's good to refresh your memory on everything that happened up to that point. The game requires focus, if you are doing anything at all at the same time, you might end up staring for hours, getting no closer to solving anything. The total playtime can vary a lot, depending on how long everything takes you. The music is awesome, the art style and direction is fresh as hell and has character. Most importantly I found the story, mystery and characters very compelling and connecting dots between everything very satisfying. Perhaps I'd prefer it if you couldn't brute force anything with the '2 or fewer' thing and I'd kill for something even more challenging in the future. If you are of a curious nature, mystery enjoyer, puzzle solver, you need to play this.
I loved the original game and the Spider of Lanka DLC, but unfortunately The Rise of Golden Idol suffers from the same flaws as the Lemurian Vampire DLC. This series is no longer about elegant logic puzzles. It’s instead a convoluted and poorly written game of Mad Libs, requiring conjecture and word swapping to ‘solve’. I abandoned it on realising how tedious I was finding the garden scenario (I was playing offline so my play time is not accurate). I think this is the end of my time with this series.
It's rare that a sequel to a good game successfully captures the magic of the original. And this one... may or may not. Depends on the player. But for everything it changes, it expands with sheer WALLs of lore. XD I enjoyed this very much, to the point where I will set it on the same quality shelf as the original. They experimented with some things, and kept true to others. There are some chapters of this game that FAR outshine the original (the apartment complex chapter is a microcosm of sheer storytelling), while still building the same world. Great game, great DLCs.
Reviews sourced from Steam. All reviews belong to their respective authors.
Data sourced from RAWG, Steam, IGDB, CheapShark, Wikipedia, HLTB, and GX Corner. Sources: rawg, steam, igdb, wikipedia.
All game titles, trademarks, and copyrights belong to their respective owners.